In my last article, A Familiar Story, I introduced Pilgrim’s Progress.1 It’s not widely known, but apart from the Bible, it is the most popular book in history. In this article, I’ll draw another insight from it—a connection Bunyan makes between a character named Legality and his son, Civility.
Another Way
In Stage One, Christian becomes painfully aware of the heavy burden on his back. His burden represents the weight of his sin. When he tells Mr. Worldly Wiseman about it, he’s met with callous indifference. Worldly Wiseman warns Christian that the way he’s going about getting his burden removed is the way of wearisomeness, painfulness, perilousness, and death. He questions why anyone would choose such a difficult path when there is a less wearisome, less painful, less perilous way.
Legality
At last, Worldly Wiseman points Christian to the nearby village of Morality. There, he is told to look for a man by the name of Legality—a judicious man with a reputation for supposedly helping men like Christian unburden themselves.
In the story, Christian never actually makes it to Legality’s house. He starts walking in the direction of Morality, but the hill leading there is so steep, and its peak is so high that he becomes overwhelmed.
What does Bunyan want us to learn from Legality?
Obviously, his name is meant to warn against the dangers of legalism—the belief that one can achieve right standing before God through personal effort. It insists that a man can pick himself up, dust himself off, and present himself to God as a worthy citizen of heaven. While misguided, legalism is the natural course of action for anyone whose heart has not been so hardened that he thinks himself to be good just the way he is. You see, the legalist knows that God is holy (Leviticus 19:2) and that he has fallen short of God’s righteous standard (Psalm 14:2-3). He is under no illusion about the eternal fate of those in his condition. He sees the precariousness of his position and understands full well that it is appointed for a man to die once, and after that comes judgment (Hebrews 9:27).
The problem with legalism is that it misunderstands what it means to have a sinful nature. Sin is not only something you do; it is also something you are. Because it is woven into the fabric of your being, it directs your thoughts, your desires, and your actions. Just as it is the nature of fire to be hot, it is the nature of fallen humanity to be sinful. You can alter your behavior, but you cannot alter your nature.
Civility
A fascinating detail emerges in Christian’s interaction with Worldly Wiseman. When Wiseman points the way to Legality’s house, he says:
You can go to him and be helped right away. His house isn’t quite a mile from here. And if he isn’t home himself, he has a son who is friendly and easy to get along with, whose name is Civility. He can assist you in the same way as his father. You can be relieved of your burden there (p. 16).
It’s interesting to me that Bunyan knew that Legality’s son would be called Civility. It’s also interesting that Bunyan never has Christian speak with him. There’s no further mention of him at all in the book. All we get is this one passing remark from Worldly Wiseman. It’s as if Bunyan places Civility just within earshot and then whispers to the reader, He who has ears to hear, let him hear.
Perhaps Bunyan doesn’t say more because, in his day, he was only able to glimpse Civility on the horizon of Christian history. I can’t be sure about that, but it seems clear to me that today’s evangelical church is no longer dominated by Legality—it is now firmly in the grip of his son.
The days of hearing about a fiery hell from our pulpits are long gone. Over the last fifty years, the American church has followed after the world in its wide embrace of tolerance—but one thing it has little or no tolerance for is Jonathan Edwards’ conception of Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God. Faithful preaching used to lift up God’s perfect law like a mirror to expose sin and call Christians to holiness (Psalm 19:7). Today, it seems like most churches have no place for truth that isn’t first swaddled warmly in the comforts of God’s grace.
Why should you beware of Legality’s son?
The answer is found in the conversation between Christian and Worldly Wiseman. Like his father, Civility offers an illegitimate way of removing your burden of sin. Whereas Legality promotes rigid adherence to God’s law as your means of righteousness, Civility swings in the opposite direction, emphasizing God’s grace to such an extreme that he eliminates the role of God’s law in directing your life. Legalism binds your conscience with rules; Civility sedates your conscience by affirming politeness, agreeability, and timidity as the marks of those who have truly experienced grace.
But in reality, Civility’s politeness is a superficial imitation of kindness; his agreeability is a gross distortion of unity; and his timidity is a hollow replacement for humility. While Legalism burdens the soul with obligations, Civility lulls it to sleep with a false sense of security.
Lord, Lord
This brings us to one of the most sobering passages in the New Testament. In the Sermon on the Mount, Jesus declares:
21 Not everyone who says to me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ will enter the kingdom of heaven, but the one who does the will of my Father who is in heaven. 22 On that day many will say to me, ‘Lord, Lord, did we not prophesy in your name, and cast out demons in your name, and do many mighty works in your name?’ 23 And then will I declare to them, ‘I never knew you; depart from me, you workers of lawlessness.’
Matthew 7:21-23
If you look at verse 21 carefully, you will notice that Jesus is highlighting two things: (1) the words you say and (2) the things you do. The first takeaway is that merely professing Jesus as your Lord and Savior—that is, what you say—is not the only question on the test for genuine belief. Don’t get me wrong, it is the first question on the test, but the second question counts for just as much. It asks: Are you a doer of God’s will?
Verses 22 and 23 are where we have to stop and think—we must not move quickly past this warning. Here, Jesus reveals the sobering reality that false professors of faith do exist. He makes it clear that a person’s actions—even if they appear to be good—must align with God’s Word, or they will ultimately be exposed as worthless. Notice that Jesus calls these false professors “workers of lawlessness.” That is to say, they don’t believe the law of God has anything to say to them. They disregard the fact that Jesus calls believers to love God and obey His commands (John 14:15).
Civility is an insidious deception because it fosters a lie that looks like real faith but lacks true submission to Christ’s authority.
Law and Gospel
This passage in Matthew 7 stresses a critical point: both what we say and what we do matter. Jesus does not commend works-based righteousness, nor does he commend faith without obedience. The issue is not merely whether you profess that Jesus is Lord, but whether your profession leads to a life of genuine submission to His will.
How do the law and the gospel work together in the Christian life?
Today, many professing Christians have been led astray by Civility. They believe that the law of God and the grace of God are opposed to each other. But this is false. The Christian life is marked by obedience to God’s law—not as a replacement for salvation by grace, but as evidence of genuine faith (James 2:17). The grace of God does not set aside the law of God—it writes it on the hearts of His people (Jeremiah 31:33). True faith produces a life that delights in God’s commands, not as a burden, but as an act of love (John 14:15).
1 I recommend the updated English version of Pilgrim’s Progress, 2nd Edition, published by Aneko Press.
